The Chicago White Sox have bolstered their starting pitching by reaching a three-year, $52.5 million agreement with right-hander Dustin May, as reported by FanSided.
The 29-year-old joins after pitching for the St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers during the 2026 season, bringing significant velocity and recent playoff experience to a Chicago club aiming to build on an unexpected return to the postseason.
While the White Sox have not formally confirmed the move, the reported deal represents a notable investment in their starting rotation ahead of the 2027 campaign.
Dustin May’s 2026 campaign and pitching metrics
May divided the 2026 season between St. Louis and Milwaukee, throwing a career-best 145⅔ innings. He posted a 4.70 ERA, though his deeper statistics suggested better results, including a 3.63 FIP and a 4.50 expected ERA.
His fastball continued to be a major asset. May averaged 96.9 mph with the pitch, ranking him 15th among 141 pitchers who threw at least 100 innings that season.
The right-hander also benefits from his relative youth. He celebrated his 29th birthday in September and has now exceeded 130 innings in back-to-back seasons following a challenging 2021-24 stretch in which he totaled only 101 innings while battling injuries, including UCL surgery.
Despite those obstacles, May still features mid-to-upper-90s velocity with his sinker. Pitching analytics have also graded his sweeper and curveball well, making him an appealing addition despite lingering questions about whether Milwaukee maximized his potential after acquiring him at the trade deadline.
Chicago’s rotation gains important depth
The White Sox’s need for starting pitching grew evident throughout the 2026 season. Chicago frequently depended on openers and bullpen games instead of conventional starters, including during their playoff appearance, when just two of their seven games featured a traditional starter.
May’s addition provides the coaching staff with another arm capable of filling a regular starting role, while his experience working out of the bullpen could also be valuable if Chicago continues to employ alternative pitching strategies.
The projected rotation depth chart now features:
-
RHP Sean Burke
-
RHP Dustin May
-
RHP Grant Taylor
-
LHP Anthony Kay
-
RHP Davis Martin
-
RHP Luis Castillo
-
LHP Noah Schultz
-
RHP David Sandlin
-
RHP Shane Smith
-
RHP Drew Thorpe
Grant Taylor is anticipated to join the rotation in 2027, offering another potential option as the White Sox seek greater consistency among their starters.
Luis Castillo’s outlook remains more complicated. After being acquired from the Seattle Mariners at the trade deadline, he performed poorly, surrendering 30 runs over 31 innings. A shoulder problem then sent him to the injured list to conclude the season.
Castillo is owed $22.75 million, which could help guarantee him a spot in the Opening Day rotation. However, Chicago has sufficient alternatives to explore other choices if his performance does not improve.
Three-year commitment signals Chicago’s rising ambitions
May was rated as the offseason’s 25th-best free agent and the 11th-best starting pitcher. His blend of relatively young age, velocity, and versatility across different pitching roles makes him an intriguing addition, even if his 2026 ERA raises some eyebrows.
He also carries postseason experience from Milwaukee’s championship run. May made two starts and three relief appearances during the Brewers’ playoff journey, showing his comfort in both capacities.
The financial commitment will also elevate Chicago’s projected 2027 payroll to $120 million, according to FanGraphs. That marks a substantial rise from the $102 million payroll the White Sox carried the previous season.
White Sox aim to build on remarkable 2026 turnaround
Chicago’s reported agreement with May follows one of the most extraordinary reversals in recent baseball history.
The White Sox concluded the 2026 regular season with an 84-78 record, earning their first playoff berth since 2021. In doing so, they became the first team in MLB history to reach the postseason after losing at least 100 games in each of the two preceding seasons.
Their recent struggles had been especially pronounced. Chicago went 61-101 in 2023, then 41-121 in 2024, and another 60-102 in 2025.
May’s arrival provides the club with another experienced arm as it seeks to convert its surprising success into lasting progress. With a deeper set of rotation options and a considerably higher projected payroll, the White Sox are gearing up for a more ambitious 2027 season.
